args[0]=message
args[1]=DB::DB::Message=HASH(0x30f5030)
Re[2]: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
11.09.2008 9:54 | Karim Haidarov
| Citata: |
| Karim! A ved' u Vas poluchaetsya, chto vse zvezdy imeyut odinakovuyu massu! Otkuda takaya uravnilovka? Ya naprimer ne soglasen s oficial'noi astrofizikoi tol'ko iz-za togo, chto ona otvodit dlya zvezd "uzkii" diapazon mass: 10^3 -10^4 mass Solnca ne ob'yasnyaya prichin ogranicheniya. |
- Pochemu Vy reshili, chto u menya vse zvezdy odinakovoi massy?
Na samom dele etogo ya nigde ne utverzhdal.
Massa zvezdy uvelichivaetsya po mere akkrecii veshestva, vklyuchaya gaz, pyl', mikrokomety, komety i pr.
do momenta krizisa (narusheniya virial'noi ustoichivosti, vzryva sverhnovoi i pr.)
- Pochemu Vy reshili, chto "oficial'naya" astrofizika otvodit dlya zvezd diapazon mass: 10^3 -10^4 mass
Solnca?
Ya schital, chto do 100 solnechnyh mass bez ogranicheniya snizu.
S etim ya soglasen, tak kak eto ne spekulyativnye vyvody teoretikov - relyativistov, no nablyudatel'nye
dannye.
"Ne ob'yasnyaya", potomu, chto v ramkah relyativistskoi fiziki etomu net ob'yasneniya.
[Citirovat'][Otvetit'][Novoe soobshenie]
| Forumy >> Obsuzhdenie publikacii Astroneta |
| Spisok / Derevo Zagolovki / Annotacii / Tekst |
- Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(L. R. Yungel'son, "Fizika Kosmosa", 1986,
8.07.2003 23:20, 7.9 KBait, otvetov: 15)
GERCShPRUNGA - RESSELLA DIAGRAMMA - grafich. izobrazhenie zavisimosti abs.... - Re: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(v. n. svetlov,
19.05.2008 13:51, 920 Bait)
Diagrammu Gercshprunga-Ressela izobrazhayut nepravil'no! Evolyuciya... - Re: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(v. n. svetlov,
20.06.2008 8:43, 254 Bait, otvetov: 4)
Vremya idet, nauka razvivaetsya. Pochemu lyudi trutsya na staryh vozreniyah?... - Re[2]: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(V. E. Krauchuk,
25.06.2008 21:06, 69 Bait, otvetov: 3)
Nu tak opiblikui s faktomy... - Re[3]: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(v. n. svetlov,
30.06.2008 12:25, 414 Bait, otvetov: 2)
Esli Vy podumaete, to, mozhet byt', chto-libo nachnete ponimat'.... - Re[4]: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(Yurii Pahomov,
5.09.2008 17:29, 927 Bait, otvetov: 1)
1) Diagramma HR iznachal'no stroilas'... - Re[5]: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(Karim Haidarov,
6.09.2008 9:57, 579 Bait)
Na samom dele sovremennaya astrofizika polna mifov.... - Re: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(V. E. Krauchuk,
9.09.2008 23:35, 619 Bait, otvetov: 1)
Soglasen s Pahomovym... - Re[2]: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(Karim Haidarov,
10.09.2008 7:43, 3.8 KBait)
- Dolzhen konstatirovat'... - Re: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(V. E. Krauchuk,
10.09.2008 23:44, 275 Bait, otvetov: 1)
Karim!... - >> Re[2]: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(Karim Haidarov,
11.09.2008 9:54, 1.1 KBait)
- Pochemu Vy reshili... - Re: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(V. E. Krauchuk,
11.09.2008 23:14, 1.7 KBait, otvetov: 3)
Karim, konechno Vy ne utverzhdali... - Re[2]: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(Karim Haidarov,
12.09.2008 8:50, 5.0 KBait, otvetov: 2)
Kravchuk: Karim, konechno... - Re[3]: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(V. E. Krauchuk,
15.09.2008 22:50, 1.3 KBait, otvetov: 1)
A, na "pal'cah" zdorovo u Vas poluchaetsya ob'yasnyat'!... - Re[4]: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(Karim Haidarov,
16.09.2008 17:52, 3.5 KBait)
prochitav Vashu stat'yu "SVERHSZhATYE SOSTOYaNIYa... - Re: Gercshprunga-Ressela diagramma
(V. E. Krauchuk,
23.09.2008 20:27, 27 Bait)
My sporim, a zvezdy SVETYaT!