Astronet > Forumy > Obsuzhdenie publikacii Astroneta > Chernye dyry: Populyarnoe vvedenie - eto znachit dlya durakov, veryashih v yabloki na bereze

Zhan-P'er Lyumine/CNRS, Medon · 25.10.2002 18:26

Osnovy nashego ponimaniya prostranstva-vremeni proveryayutsya chernymi dyrami. Eti ob'ekty, poyavlyayushiesya kak estestvennoe sledstvie uravnenii obshei teorii otnositel'nosti, - moshnoe analiticheskoe sredstvo issledovaniya mikroskopicheskih i krupnomasshtabnyh svoistv vselennoi. Dannaya vvodnaya stat'ya naglyadno izlagaet osnovnye idei teorii chernyh dyr, a takzhe opisyvaet astronomicheskie ob'ekty, v kotoryh, kak predpolagaetsya, oni igrayut vazhnuyu
>> Prochitat' stat'yu

M. F. Dmitriev · 24.12.2002 13:36

hME, 'M H VEPMYu' DShPYu. oHYaELN mP.11. oNYaB'YYuERYa' oERPS iYuOHZhYu. vEPMYu' DShPYu H YaBEPUMNBYu' GBEGDYu ShRN DBYu NAZE'RYu YaB'GYuMMShU LEFDS YaNANI YaRYuAHKEMShL OKYuGLEMMShL 'MSPNL. shRN hME H 'M. oN LEPE MYu'NOKEMH' LYuREPHH B NCPNLMNI VEPMNI GBEGDE, YaHYaRELYu YaRYuMNBHREYa' BYaE ANKEE H ANKEE MESYaRNIVHBNI. b 'NMZhE 'NMZhNB, BYaKEDYaRBHE BNGMH'YuChYHU BNGLSYEMHI, CDE RN OPNHYaUNDHR OPNPShB H SREV'Yu LYuREPHYuKYu. oKYuGLEMMShI 'MSP OEPE'YuVHBYuER ShMEPCHCh LYuREPHCh GYu OPEDEKSh ONK' R'CNREMH' VEPMNI GBEGDSh B YaRNPNMS NAZE'RYu BShGBYuB'ECN BNGLSYEMHE Ya ZhEKECh GYuUBYuRHE ECN. mN RYuL, CDE ONKE R'CNREMH' VEPMNI GBEGDSh MYuVHMYuER DNYaRHCYuRE GMYuVEMHI YaNONYaRYuBHLShU Ya N'PSFYuChYHL TNMNL 'NYaLHVEYa'NCN OPNYaRPYuMYaRBYu, CDE OPNRHBNONKNFMShE YaHKSh PYuBMSh MSKCh, RYuL BNGMH'YuER YaBEPUMNBYu' GBEGDYu. iNRNPYu' Ya MNBNI YaHKNI MYuVHMYuER OEPE'YuVHBYuRE LYuREPHCh MYu YaEA', OPHDYuBYu' OPNZhEYaYaS SYaRNIVHBShI, MENAPYuRHLShI UYuPYu'REP. yaBEPUMNBYu' GBEGDYu BShYaYuYaShBYuER LYuREPHCh MYu YaEA' HG VEPMNI GBEGDSh. mEYaLNRP' MYu OEPBNMYuVYuKEMNE, CKNAYuKEMNE MEYaNNRBERYaRBHE LYuYa'RYuANB NDMNCN NAZE'RYu DPSCNLS, VEPMYu' GBEGDYu ME LNFER OPNRHBNYaRN'RE NRRN'S LYuREPHH HG MEE ONYa'NKE'S, NAPYuGMN CNBNP' NMYu ONOYuKYu B RYu'NI BNDNBNPNR HG 'NRNPNCN ME LNFER BShAPYuREYa'. bNPNM'S, 'NRNPYu' EYaKH H ME BShYaNYaER BYaE DN DMYu, RN NYaRYuBHR FYuK'HE 'PNUH B BHDE NYaRShBYuChYECN 'YuPKH'Yu. sBHDERE OKYuGLEMMShI FCSR YaN YaRNPNMSh VEPMNI DShPSh ME OPEDYaRYuBK'ERYa' BNGLNFMShL. bOPNVEL RYu'FE, 'Yu' H YaN YaRNPNMSh YaBEPUMNBNI GBEGDSh. rYu'FE, 'Yu' H YaAN'S ShRN NVEME YaKNFMN GYuLERHRE ON ONM'RMShL OPHVHMYuL. mYuHANKEE MYuCK'DMYu' YuMYuKNCH' OPNHYaUNDHR B BYuMMNI 'NLMYuRE, 'NCDYu BNDYu MYuVHMYuER BShAECYuRE B BNDNBNPNRE B BHDE BNPNM'H. rNKE'N LSh BHDHL NDMS YaRNPNMS OPNZhEYaYaYu. eYaKH ASh LSh LNCKH GYuCK'MSRE ON DPSCSCh YaRNPNMS, LSh ASh SBHDEKH VRN RN ONDNAMNE GYuPNFDEMHCh MNBNI GBEGDSh. b SYaKNBH'U 'NYaLHVEYa'NCN OPNYaRPYuMYaRBYu PYuGAECYuMHE LYuREPHH MYuONLHMYuKN ASh TNPLS PYuGAECYuChYHUYa' CYuKYu'RH'. rE FE OPNZhEYaYaSh LSh BHDHL B BNGDS'MNI YaPEDE ShRN YaLEPVE, RNPMYuDN. oNVELS B 'NYaLHVEYa'NL OPNYaRPYuMYaRBE ME LNFER AShRE REU FE OPNZhEYaYaNB? bOPNVEL ON BYaEL YaNOSRYaRBSChYHL BNOPNYaYuL EYaRE OPE'PYuYaMShE YaOEZhHYuKHYaRSh. hL H 'YuPRSh B PS'H. nDMNBPELEMMN, HYaYaKEDNBYuMHE ShRNI CHONREGSh, ' ONKYuCYuCh ONGBNKHR RNVMEE NOHYaYuRE OPNZhEYaYaSh HLEMMN B ShRHU SG'HU NAKYuYaR'U. iYu' LME BHDHREYa', NYaMNBMShE TSMDYuLEMRYuKEMShE HYaYaKEDNBYuMH', 'NRNPShLH GYuMHLYuKYa' oERP iYuOHZhYu, REL HKH DPSCHL NAPYuGNL LNCSR AShRE OPHLEMHLSh OPH NRPYuANR'E ShRNI CHONREGSh. lNFER AShRE NM OPNYaRN ME SYaOEK NAZEDHMHRE HU B NDMN ZhEKNE. eYaKH bYuL HMREPEYaMN, DYuIRE GMYuRE. ya SBYuFEMHEL lHUYuHK dLHRPHEB maikl52@hot.ee 9 DE'YuAP' 2002 CNDYu.

M. F. Dmitriev · 26.12.2002 14:11

Otvet na Vashu stat'yu s kommentariyami chitaite v "In', Yan i chernaya dyra" po adresu: http://www.izvestia.ru/forum/forums.cgi?forum=12

M. F. Dmitriev · 26.12.2002 15:23

eYaKH HYaUNDHRE HG CHONREGSh hME, 'M H VEPMYu' DShPYu, http://www.izvestia.ru/forum/forums.cgi?forum=12 RN MENAUNDHLN BMEYaRH ONOPYuB'H Ya SVERNL GYu'PSVHBYuChYEIYa' YaOHPYuKH B: pHYaSM'H 8 H 9. mYuBHCYuZhHNMMShE N'PSFMNYaRH B BNDNBNPNRE VEPMNI DShPSh. pHYaSMN' 15. iPNRNBYu' MNPYu B OPNYaRPYuMYaRBE-BPELEMH. pHYaSMN' 16. hGSVEMHE YaTEPHVEYa'NI VEPMNI DShPSh Ya ONLNYECh DHYuCPYuLLSh iPSYa'YuKYu yaKEDSER ONYaRYuBHRE OND YaNLMEMHE YaKEDSChYHE SRBEPFDEMH' YuBRNPYu: nDMYu'N 'YaMN, VRN VEPEG 'PNRNBSCh MNPS MEKEG' OPNIRH ON BPELEMHONDNAMNI RPYuE'RNPHH: MH NDMYu RPYuE'RNPH' ME LNFER BEYaRH HG NDMNI BYaEKEMMNI B DPSCSCh, ME OPNUND' VEPEG YaHMCSK'PMNYaRE OPH . ... yu ShRN ME DYuER MH EDHMNCN 'YuMYaYu DK' OSRE'EYaRBHI B OPNYaRPYuMYaRBE-BPELEMH... bOPNVEL RYu'FE, 'Yu' H BN BYaE YaNOSRYaRBSChYHE, NYaMNBNONKNCYuChYHE ONKNFEMH' YaNBPELEMMNI THGH'H. ' ONKYuCYuCh OSRE'EYaRBNBYuRE BN BPELEMH LNFMN. rNKE'N 'Yu' ShRN YaDEKYuRE, VRNASh ME NAFEVE YaBNH 'PShKE' ONDNAMN RPEREEI AYuANV'E? mE YaLNRP' MYu RN, VRN ' YuAYaNKChRMShI MENTHR B ShRNL BNOPNYaE, ME HLEChYHI MH'Yu'NI RENPERHVEYa'NI ONDCNRNB'H 'PNLE MYuSVMNONOSK'PMNI, LME 'YuFERYa' ' LNCS DYuRE SG'NYaOEZhHYuKHGHPNBYuMMShL SVEMShL ONDYa'YuG'S DK' NRBERYu MYu ShRNR BNOPNYa. oNRNLS VRN ME GMYu' TNPLSK, ' GMYuCh 'Yu' HYa'YuRE NRBER. ya SBYuFEMHEL ' ONVREMMNI OSAKH'E, MShME AEGPYuANRMShI DHPE'RNP ON KNCHYaRH'E lHUYuHK dLHRPHEB. maikl52@hot.ee 26 DE'YuAP' 2002 C.

Gost' · 11.08.2005 18:15

Zhzhesh scuko!!!

Gost' · 27.01.2006 10:09

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

I. A. )))) · 21.01.2008 15:32

Srochno nuzhno mnogo informacii pro Chernye Dyry za poslednii 5 LET!!! I esli est' roliki pro pogloshenie ChD zvezd ili inyh ob'ektov!esli u kogo-to chto-to podobnoe est', vysylaite na mylo koncepciya@gmail.com Budu och priznatel'na!

i. e. Abevegedeev · 26.04.2009 17:08

"ves' izluchennyi takim telom svet dolzhen byl by k nemu vernut'sya" .hME, 'M H VEPMYu' DShPYu. oHYaELN mP.11. oNYaB'YYuERYa' oERPS iYuOHZhYu. vEPMYu' DShPYu H YaBEPUMNBYu' GBEGDYu ShRN DBYu NAZE'RYu YaB'GYuMMShU LEFDS YaNANI YaRYuAHKEMShL OKYuGLEMMShL 'MSPNL. Nu vot.Pervoe soobshenie iz chernoi dyry prorvalos' naruzhu.

i. e. Abevegedeev · 26.04.2009 20:34

Re[2]: vEPMShE DShPSh: oNOSK'PMNE BBEDEMHE 26.04.2009 17:08 "ves' izluchennyi takim telom svet dolzhen byl by k nemu vernut'sya" .hME, 'M H VEPMYu' DShPYu. oHYaELN mP.11. oNYaB'YYuERYa' oERPS iYuOHZhYu. vEPMYu' DShPYu H YaBEPUMNBYu' GBEGDYu ShRN DBYu NAZE'RYu YaB'GYuMMShU LEFDS YaNANI YaRYuAHKEMShL OKYuGLEMMShL 'MSPNL. Nu vot.Pervoe soobshenie iz chernoi dyry prorvalos' naruzhu.

Karim Haidarov · 27.04.2009 8:46

Nu i proidoha, etot Zhan-P'er Lyumine iz Observatorii Parizh-Myudon, Otdeleniya Relyativistskoi Astrofiziki i Kosmologii!!! ... zhalko trud pekrevodchika etoi brehni (zhizn' to, daetsya nam odin raz i ne na dolgo).

Nachav, yakoby, s persidskoi skazki, on kak drevnii haldeiskii mag, vnushaet chitatelyu, chto i na bereze rastut yabloki.

Na samom dele chernyh dyr net v prirode po prostoi prichine: elemtromagnitnye volny ne obladayut gravitacionnoi massoi, a poetomu ne uchastvuyut v gravitacionnom vzaimodeistvii i ne mogut letat' po obbitam konicheskih sechenii. Poetomu vse dal'neishie rassuzhdeniya "skol'ko yablok na vetkah berezy" - prosto bessmyslenny, esli ne skazat' - zhul'nicheskii relyativsistskii cirk.

Kto hochet deistvitel'no razobrat'sya s problemoi kvazarov i rentgenovskih zvezd, chitaite ne etu mut', a stat'i vedushih uchenyh planety - astrofizikov i fizikov na saite Bourabai Research

Dlya nachala tam est' FAQ dlya "chainikov"

A. V. Rykov · 13.05.2009 10:33

Zhalkoe zrelishe proizvodyat KM, KED, OTO!

Prichina obshaya dlya vseh fundamental'nyh fizicheskih teorii HH veka: bez znaniya prirody yavlenii vsemi vozmozhnymi sposobami matematicheski opisyvayut nablyudaemye yavleniya i dannye eksperimentov. Deistvuya v tochnosti po receptam Ptolemeya-Dekarta. Na samom dele parametry chernyh dyr opredelyayutsya po N'yutonu, a ne po Shvarcshil'du. Radius chernoi dyry nahoditsya po formule N'yutona R=sqrt[GM/g(max)], gde g(max)=6,341445e+10 mc^2.