Astronet > Forumy > Astronomiya i Internet

po tekstam po forumu vnutri temy

args[0]=message
args[1]=DB::DB::Message=HASH(0x3a95f00)
Re[4]: Novaya astrofizika
12.05.2011 0:53 | M. Yu. Yakimov

Nauka ne ob'yasnyaet, uvy, kak, mozhet byt',nadeyutsya diletanty ot nauki. Nauka tol'ko ustanavlivaet fakty, yavleniyai vzaimosvyaz' mezhdu nimi. Ob'yasnyat' - v smysle svodit' k obydennym ponyatiyam dazhe to, chto svesti k nim nel'zya- udel filosofov i dosuzhih boltunov, prichem pervoe chasto trudno otlichit' ot vtorogo. V nastoyashee vremya sushestvuet odna teoriya gravitacii, kotoraya real'norabotaet i poetomumozhet schitat'syadostatochno obosnovannoi - eto, konechno, OTO. Chto kasaetsya RTG Logunova - ne ponimayu, zachem ona nuzhna - preimushestv pered OTO u nee net. Bol'she, chem "ob'yasnyayut" populyarnye izlozheniya OTO, ya "ob'yasnit'" ne smogu. Da i OTO vovse ne ob'yasnyaet, chto takoe gravitaciya. Eto i ne udivitel'no - zakon Guka ne ob'yasnyaet, chto takoe uprugost', zakon Oma ne ob'yasnyaet, chto takoe soprotivlenie. No otsutstvie "ob'yasnenii" ne otmenyaet teorii yavleniya, i umenie obrashat'sya s takimi teoriyami obyazatel'no dlya teh, kto zanimaetsya fizikoi i tehnikoi. To zhe mozhno skazat'i pro OTO. A "ob'yasnenie" - ishite ego gde-nibud' v drugom meste, no ne trogaite, pozhaluista OTO. Ved' ne otmenyayut zhe molekulyarnaya fizikai fizika tverdogo tela teorii uprugosti i elektricheskih cepei. "Ob'yasnenie" - pustyshka, surrogat znaniya, i chasto profanaciya. Istinnoe znanie - znanie prirodnyh vzaimosvyazei i umenie imi operirovat'. Kriterii nauchnogo professionalizma - umenie predvidet' hod veshei v razlichnyh situaciyah, teoreticheskoe predskazanie uslovii i eksperimental'noe obnaruzhenie novyh yavlenii i novyh vzaimosvyazei na osnove imeyushegosya znaniya. Esli u vas etogo net, to u vas net nauki, i uchenomu vy ne interesny, dazhe s samymi original'nymi "ob'yasneniyami".

Forumy >> Astronomiya i Internet

Spisok / Derevo
Zagolovki / Annotacii / Tekst

Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 4.05.2011 11:52, 982 Bait, otvetov: 45)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 4.05.2011 20:32, 354 Bait)
Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 4.05.2011 20:37, 243 Bait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 5.05.2011 6:28, 245 Bait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 5.05.2011 8:43, 939 Bait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 5.05.2011 13:07, 1.3 KBait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 5.05.2011 19:54, 213 Bait)
Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 5.05.2011 20:06, 619 Bait)
Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 5.05.2011 20:28, 648 Bait, otvetov: 2)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 7.05.2011 20:29, 4 Bait, otvetov: 1)

Re[3]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 7.05.2011 20:32, 999 Bait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 9.05.2011 13:12, 1008 Bait, otvetov: 2)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (M. Yu. Yakimov, 10.05.2011 1:22, 366 Bait, otvetov: 1)

Re[3]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 10.05.2011 7:45, 1.9 KBait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 10.05.2011 20:15, 768 Bait, otvetov: 8)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (M. Yu. Yakimov, 11.05.2011 9:35, 159 Bait, otvetov: 7)

Re[3]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 11.05.2011 10:24, 475 Bait, otvetov: 6)

>> Re[4]: Novaya astrofizika (M. Yu. Yakimov, 12.05.2011 0:53, 1.7 KBait, otvetov: 5)

Re[5]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 12.05.2011 7:21, 1.6 KBait, otvetov: 4)

Re[6]: Novaya astrofizika (M. Yu. Yakimov, 12.05.2011 23:34, 1.2 KBait, otvetov: 3)

Re[7]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 13.05.2011 6:50, 820 Bait, otvetov: 2)

Re[8]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 15.05.2011 18:07, 4 Bait, otvetov: 1)

Re[9]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 28.05.2011 6:59, 2.7 KBait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 28.05.2011 9:28, 1.7 KBait)
Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 28.05.2011 9:53, 626 Bait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 29.05.2011 8:40, 2.2 KBait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 29.05.2011 13:37, 5.1 KBait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 29.05.2011 15:18, 107 Bait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 29.05.2011 17:29, 870 Bait)
Re: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 29.05.2011 18:19, 355 Bait)
Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 29.05.2011 19:46, 992 Bait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 29.05.2011 20:36, 712 Bait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 29.05.2011 21:53, 13.0 KBait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 30.05.2011 6:36, 245 Bait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 30.05.2011 9:54, 2.1 KBait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 30.05.2011 10:12, 361 Bait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 30.05.2011 10:34, 1.4 KBait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 30.05.2011 11:23, 2.2 KBait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 30.05.2011 18:26, 2.0 KBait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 30.05.2011 19:37, 405 Bait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 30.05.2011 22:26, 1.5 KBait)
Re: Novaya astrofizika (A.P. Vasi, 30.05.2011 22:36, 222 Bait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (A. V. Rykov, 31.05.2011 10:01, 58 Bait)

Re: Novaya astrofizika (A. S. N'yuton, 16.12.2011 17:08, 355 Bait, otvetov: 1)

Re[2]: Novaya astrofizika (V. V. Komogorov, 13.01.2012 23:35, 744 Bait)

Re: NOVY' SA'T ASTRONOMII (aaaf aaa, 12.01.2012 16:43, 536 Bait)