args[0]=message
args[1]=DB::DB::Message=HASH(0x614d860)
Re: Chernaya dyra
23.09.2014 22:17 | A.P. Vasi
\\\Vot i leto proshlo
26 avgusta 2014goda. TrV 161, c.1, 3, "Obrazovanie"Egor Bazykin, Dmitrii Vibe, Aleksei Sgibnev, Vladimir Surdin,
Sergei Belkov, Irina Levontina
Dmitrii Vibe,
dokt. fiz.-mat. nauk, zav. otdelom fiziki i evolyucii zvezd Instituta
astronomii RAN:
Leto s nauchnoi tochki zreniya okazalos' neozhidanno produktivnym.
Neozhidanno ibo ne po nashei
vole do leta zatyanulas' bitva s
recenzentom stat'i, kotoruyu my otpravili v zhurnal eshe v sentyabre
2013 goda. On neskol'ko raz treboval
sushestvennyh dorabotok, na
kotorye uhodil ne odin mesyac, i sam kazhdyi
raz chestno vyderzhival
mesyac na napisanie ocherednogo otzyva. Trudno
skazat', napisali li
my v itoge chto-to ego ustroivshee ili prosto nadoeli. Spravedlivosti
radi sleduet otmetit', chto vse zamechaniya byli po sushestvu, i stat'ya v
rezul'tate ih realizacii stala luchshe na kachestvennom urovne.
Stat'ya posvyashena analizu nablyudenii policiklicheskih aromaticheskih
uglevodorodov (to est' my podozrevaem, chto eto oni) vo vnegalakticheskih
oblastyah zvezdoobrazovaniya raznogo vozrasta. Do etogo odni lyudi
predpolagali, chto uglevodorody v oblastyah zvezdoobrazovaniya rastut,
drugie lyudi predpolagali, chto uglevodorody v oblastyah zvezdoobrazovaniya
razrushayutsya. Nam zhe vpervye udalos' ubeditel'no pokazat', chto tam s
uglevodorodami proishodit voobshe ne poimi chto.\\\
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Smeshno
samo zhelanie mahrovyh relyativistov podat'sya v al'ty,
sobstvenno ya ponimayu chto kushat' ohota, i podash'sya kuda ugodno,
tem bolee /esli tot kto zhivet
proshlym ne mozhet uvidet' budushee/(S),
i chto v etom sluchai delat'?.
Zdes' hot' rolik snimai - "Kak relyativisty podalis' v al'ty, i pri etom
oni
oni ostalis' relyativistami, - v itoge sredi al'tov oni - relyativisty,
a sredi relyativistov oni - al'ty.
U menya myslenno azh klaviatura utopala v slezah
vysoko intellektual'noi
rapsodii kotoraya zvuchala ot ih padeniya i udarov o plastik .
- Samoe glavnoe v etoi botve - chtoby ne bylo bazovyh i odnoznachnyh
avtorskih opredelenii. Bez etoi botvy prosto bezdna samyh umnyh -
pri etom nikto ni na chto ne neset otvetstvennosti, i tem bolee u nego
ostaetsya
vozmozhnost' vsegda samogo sebya oprovergnut', i dazhe ne odin raz
v ramkah odnoi i toi-zhe - botvy, pardon - teorii.
[Citirovat'][Otvetit'][Novoe soobshenie]
Forumy >> Obsuzhdenie publikacii Astroneta |
Spisok / Derevo Zagolovki / Annotacii / Tekst |
- Chernaya dyra (I. D. Novikov, "Fizika Kosmosa", 1986, 26.03.2003 19:16, 22.4 KBait, otvetov: 659)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (oliya Korobeinikova, 11.12.2010 19:41, 362 Bait, otvetov: 3)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (s. a. veprev, 16.12.2010 11:38, 738 Bait)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (s. a. veprev, 16.12.2010 11:38, 738 Bait)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (Vlad Loginov, 18.12.2010 20:58, 147 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A. V. Rykov, 12.12.2010 14:34, 3.7 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (V. V. Komogorov, 13.12.2010 19:38, 956 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (G. V. Fiveiskii, 23.12.2010 14:19, 270 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 25.12.2010 0:36, 635 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.12.2010 14:31, 756 Bait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (A. V. Postnikov, 5.03.2016 13:41, 953 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.12.2010 14:43, 318 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 26.12.2010 20:48, 1.5 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 27.12.2010 17:56, 1.5 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 28.12.2010 20:38, 2.1 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 29.12.2010 23:24, 1019 Bait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 30.12.2010 8:34, 744 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.12.2010 16:53, 1.8 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.12.2010 17:13, 507 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.12.2010 17:29, 397 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.12.2010 21:23, 911 Bait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 31.12.2010 17:32, 1.9 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 31.12.2010 17:00, 571 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 31.12.2010 18:31, 2.2 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 1.01.2011 15:22, 1.0 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 1.01.2011 16:59, 1.2 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 1.01.2011 19:23, 1.4 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 1.01.2011 20:21, 886 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 1.01.2011 21:18, 1.3 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 2.01.2011 12:26, 189 Bait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 2.01.2011 23:08, 708 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 3.01.2011 9:48, 2.8 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 3.01.2011 10:52, 1.9 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 3.01.2011 15:36, 2.1 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 3.01.2011 16:25, 3.5 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 3.01.2011 22:16, 3.2 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 3.01.2011 23:12, 253 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 3.01.2011 23:15, 253 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 3.01.2011 23:16, 253 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 4.01.2011 0:08, 1.3 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 4.01.2011 6:14, 1.7 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 4.01.2011 8:37, 1.4 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 4.01.2011 9:27, 2.9 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 5.01.2011 13:35, 1.9 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (G. A. Zubkov, 5.01.2011 18:34, 627 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 5.01.2011 19:55, 2.3 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 8.01.2011 10:41, 1.8 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 16.01.2011 12:46, 1.5 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 16.01.2011 13:13, 656 Bait, otvetov: 2)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (S. V. Semenov, 7.01.2013 9:26, 1.1 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[3]: Chernaya dyra (Yu. S. Reshnikov, 7.01.2013 11:42, 583 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 16.01.2011 21:21, 1.7 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra kak super kollaedr (L. L. luyko, 15.02.2011 13:47, 2.5 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 16.04.2011 11:00, 968 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (s. s. pogosyan, 17.04.2011 9:15, 232 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (L. L. Li, 24.05.2011 5:20, 2.5 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (s. s. pogosyan, 24.05.2011 9:32, 1.2 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 25.05.2011 8:38, 1.3 KBait, otvetov: 2)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (M. Yu. Yakimov, 25.05.2011 9:56, 1.1 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[3]: Chernaya dyra (M. Yu. Yakimov, 25.05.2011 10:05, 539 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 25.05.2011 21:22, 11.4 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (M. Yu. Yakimov, 27.05.2011 7:00, 746 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 27.05.2011 8:27, 922 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 27.05.2011 9:11, 627 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 7.06.2011 19:14, 916 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 14.08.2011 10:47, 1.3 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 14.08.2011 11:07, 3.1 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A. P. Ivanov, 2.09.2011 12:29, 290 Bait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (V. V. Komogorov, 5.09.2011 15:13, 554 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 16.09.2011 23:37, 1.0 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 17.09.2011 0:00, 544 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 17.09.2011 17:42, 1.0 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (A. S. Vishnevskii, 19.09.2011 2:13, 1.2 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 19.09.2011 11:14, 4.7 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 19.09.2011 11:38, 28.3 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 19.09.2011 14:51, 2.3 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 20.09.2011 9:05, 1.8 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 20.09.2011 9:19, 952 Bait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.10.2011 13:01, 2.2 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 25.11.2011 22:58, 1.6 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.11.2011 0:17, 1.1 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.11.2011 12:17, 3.4 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.11.2011 13:40, 3.8 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.11.2011 14:20, 687 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.11.2011 14:46, 1.7 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.11.2011 16:48, 1.7 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.11.2011 19:08, 1.4 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 30.11.2011 23:42, 1.3 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 2.12.2011 9:29, 744 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 2.12.2011 9:42, 346 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 2.12.2011 19:45, 288 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 3.12.2011 15:57, 4.1 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 3.12.2011 16:02, 72 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 14.12.2011 9:57, 1.4 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 18.12.2011 19:12, 959 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 25.12.2011 16:17, 2.6 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 17.01.2012 0:13, 2.0 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 17.01.2012 0:43, 1.8 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (O. E. Korobeinikova, 24.01.2012 21:04, 1.1 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (O. E. Korobeinikova, 4.02.2012 15:21, 31 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 4.02.2012 17:59, 816 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (O. E. Korobeinikova, 5.02.2012 21:49, 111 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 5.02.2012 23:34, 802 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 6.02.2012 21:27, 885 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 6.02.2012 21:30, 2.2 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 7.02.2012 1:47, 1.6 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 7.02.2012 16:42, 2.2 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 12.02.2012 14:35, 2.7 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 12.02.2012 15:24, 2.3 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 12.02.2012 15:31, 469 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 12.02.2012 18:24, 2.9 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 13.02.2012 1:12, 1.6 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 13.02.2012 1:29, 409 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 13.02.2012 15:46, 2.3 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (O. E. Korobeinikova, 14.02.2012 18:58, 53 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 15.02.2012 21:56, 460 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 15.02.2012 22:09, 804 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 15.02.2012 22:18, 2.9 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 18.02.2012 1:11, 1.6 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 18.02.2012 1:15, 183 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 18.02.2012 11:58, 1.4 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 19.02.2012 14:10, 1.3 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 19.02.2012 18:08, 817 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 24.02.2012 3:41, 932 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 24.02.2012 22:40, 1.1 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.02.2012 1:52, 1.4 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.02.2012 10:27, 14.1 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.02.2012 10:45, 972 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.02.2012 11:03, 1.2 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.02.2012 11:20, 182 Bait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.02.2012 11:59, 1.5 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.02.2012 12:12, 1.0 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.02.2012 12:19, 2.5 KBait)
- Re: Chernaya dyra (A.P. Vasi, 26.02.2012 12:21, 1.